His sisters were both ringette players, and Carter's parents made the decision to start him in the same sport when he first took to the ice.
"I actually started off playing ringette," Gylander explained. "I have two older sisters and having three different minor associations wouldn't really fit into the schedule, so I started playing ringette with my sister Brittaney."
Ringette is a game similar to hockey, where players use a stick with a blade to propel a rubber ring toward the net. Ringette got him on the ice on skates, and it's how he ended up between the posts.
"I started playing goalie in my last year in ringette and never looked back," said Gylander, who made the switch to hockey in his novice season. "At first, I could never see myself as a goalie. I always loved scoring goals. It's kind of weird how it happened."
Like a lot of kids, the intrigue of strapping on the pads was a pull that ultimately, he could not resist.
"It kind of just caught my attention," Gylander said. "Halfway through the ringette season, my coach asked if I wanted to play goalie. I said, 'Yeah, sure. Why not?' "Obviously the gear was pretty cool. That was one of the factors that influenced me just to try it out. Ever since then I loved it.
"That's when it started."
Where it's gone to has put Gylander, 18, into a position where he's a legitimate NHL prospect. The Wings selected the 6-foot-4, 170-pound Edmonton-born netminder 191st overall in the 2019 NHL entry draft.
This season with the first-place Sherwood Park Crusaders of the Alberta Junior Hockey League, Gylander led the league in wins (34), goals-against average (2.07) and save percentage (.924).
Gylander and goalie partner Jordan Frey won the AJHL Top Team Goaltending Award. Gylander was awarded the Friends of AJHL Trophy as the league's top goaltender.