With Evgeni Malkin making his playoff debut tonight, Gaudreau moved from centering the third line to playing right wing with Carter and McCann, and the trio picked up where they left off in terms of chemistry.
Gaudreau did a great job of setting Carter up for his first goal, which came just 2:31 after the Islanders had evened the score. Gaudreau broke the puck out of his own end before taking a hit to make a play and putting the puck in a spot where Carter could pick it up in stride. He skated in and sniped a no-look shot far side past Islanders goalie Semyon Varlamov.
"You can't teach that," defenseman Kris Letang said. "That's pure goal-scoring ability. It's been really good for us since he got with our team. It's a tough shot. I don't know if he expected it, but I know he's one of the guys that can make it happen. It was just an unbelievable shot."
The Penguins then entered the third period with a 3-1 lead. After the Islanders scored to cut the deficit to one, a huge scrum erupted at the Penguins net that led to all 10 skaters on the ice heading to their respective penalty boxes. Jake Guentzel was assessed an extra slashing call, which sent the Islanders to the power play. They needed all of nine seconds to convert.
When the Penguins had a power play of their own shortly after, Carter moved onto the first unit since Letang, Guentzel and Bryan Rust were all still in the box. He took a pass from Malkin at the bottom of the circle, went backhand to forehand and beat Varlamov for the second time.
"It was a bit of a roller coaster tonight," Carter said. "Up two going into the third, give it back and then all hell kind of broke loose there. But we stuck with it. It's a resilient group. You give one up, you get right back on the horse and get working. A real strong game in that sense from our team tonight, sticking with it, grinding it out and ultimately getting the win."
The Islanders did end up tying the score yet again, making it 4-4 with 5:43 left to play. But Tanev - aka the Sheriff - got on his own horse and netted the winner with 3:36 remaining in regulation. And as the clock ticked down, Carter was one of the players on the ice helping to preserve the lead.
"He's just a really tough player to play against," Letang said. "He's got the size and the skill and the speed. So to have him on our side, it's a big boost."