| Date | Opponent | Promotion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thursday, October 4 |  | Magnetic Schedule presented by UPMC, LED Wand presented by NHL Network |  |
| Tuesday, October 16 |  | Team Calendar presented by Highmark & Penguins Foundation Score Against Hunger Food Drive |  |
| Tuesday, October 30 |  | Collection Benefiting Victims/Families of the Tragedy at the Tree of Life Synagogue | |
| Monday, November 5 |  | "Join the Fight Against Cancer" T-Shirt presented by UPMC Hillman Cancer Center & Hockey Fights Cancer Night |  |
| Saturday, November 10 |  | Veterans Day Tribute | |
| Monday, November 19 |  | Sidney Crosby Bobblehead presented by UPMC |  |
| Saturday, December 1 |  | Penguins Foundation Toy Drive supporting U.S. Marine Corps Toys for Tots & 96.1KISS Stuff-A-Bus | |
| Tuesday, December 4 |  | Penguins Ball Cap presented by PPG |  |
| Thursday, December 6 | | Theme Night: Superhero | |
| Friday, December 14 |  | Team Yearbook presented by Point Park University |  |
| Monday, December 17 |  | Evgeni Malkin Bobblehead presented by UPMC Sports Medicine |  |
| Thursday, December 20 |  | Theme Night: Ugly Holiday Sweater | |
| Sunday, January 6 |  | 2009 Stanley Cup Champions Trading Cards - Upper Deck |  |
| Tuesday, January 8 |  | Theme Night: 70s | |
| Monday, January 28 |  | Kris Letang Bobblehead presented by UPMC |  |
| Friday, February 1 |  | Check Your Heart Tumbler presented by UPMC Heart & Vascular Institute and American Heart Association |  |
| Tuesday, February 5 |  | Theme Night: 80s | |
| Saturday, February 16 |  | "Pens Logo" 500-piece Puzzle presented by PPG (Artist: Johno Prascak) |  |
| Tuesday, March 5 |  | Theme Night: 90s | |
| Sunday, March 10 |  | Magnetic Air Vent Mount presented by Western PA Honda Dealers |  |
| Sunday, March 17 | | PA Lottery Scratch Off Coupon presented by PA Lottery* | |
| Friday, March 29 |  | Penguins Foundation Pet Supplies Collection supporting Humane Animal Rescue | |
| Saturday, April 6 |  | Fan Appreciation Night |
