Overcoming the pain of injury and becoming the hero that lifted the Penguins into their second consecutive Stanley Cup Final.
The storyline was almost too easy. In fact, it was too easy.
Three minutes later, Ottawa's Erik Karlsson drilled a shot off the post and Ryan Dzingel pounced on the rebound to tie the game. The pesky Senators would not go quietly.
When the clock struck zero, a new hero was to be crowned. The next goal scorer would win the game, win the series and carry his team into the Stanley Cup Final.
There is nothing quite like an overtime in the NHL playoffs. Your nerves are completely fried and your heart rate accelerates with every shot. Amplify that by 100 and that's overtime in a Game 7 in the NHL playoffs.
Toss in what was at stake - the winner advancing to the Stanley Cup Final and the Penguins playing for history, attempting to become the first team in nearly two decades to repeat as champions - and you have the most intense cocktail of anxiety and adrenaline.
This contest lived up to the billing.
The Penguins dominated the opening overtime, and came close on several occasions to ending the series. In fact, sniper Phil Kessel had a lot of those chances.
Kessel carried the puck down the near side with no one around him after catching the Senators in a line change, but his shot went wide far side of the post. Minutes later Brian Dumoulin nearly scored when Ottawa goaltender Craig Anderson appeared to be unset for a shot. Anderson, though, reacted at the last minute to get a pad down and kick the puck aside. Late in the overtime, Kessel swerved around a defender and cut to the net. The puck popped up into the air and rolled atop the net before falling down on the other side.
The Penguins outshot Ottawa, 8-2, in the opening overtime session. Both Ottawa shots were harmless and the bulk of the period was played in the Senators zone. Despite Pittsburgh's domination and scoring chances, the first overtime came and went scoreless.
The tension was palpable in the arena. No matter how good the Penguins were playing, it only took one fluky shot for their entire season to come crashing down.