Varlamov's Game 3 start was his second back after missing Game 1 because of an undisclosed reason. Shortly into his return in Game 2, Varlamov gave up a goal on a simple shot from forward Bryan Rust past his glove at 3:22 of the first.
But after that goal, and one by forward Jeff Carter at 13:07 of the first, Varlamov was perfect, totaling 43 saves in a 2-1 loss.
Varlamov's outing in Game 3 put his status into question, though. It doesn't help his cause that Sorokin impressed in his Stanley Cup Playoffs debut in Game 1, when he outperformed Penguins goalie Tristan Jarry for his first NHL postseason win.
After indicating he could turn to Sorokin for Saturday, Trotz said Varlamov was better than he remembered in Game 3. So which way New York will go remains unknown.
"One thing about [Varlamov] is he's as good a pro as you're going to find," Trotz said. "He responds really well in terms of getting back into his zone, if you will."