With the Islanders applying much of the pressure early on in the opening period, the Panthers flipped the script when Bennett, who was battling with a defenseman in front of New York's net, banged home a rebound after a quick shot from Radko Gudas at 9:10 to make it a 1-0 contest.
Capping off a milestone moment in the second period, Bennett, who clearly was feeling fine despite missing practice on Friday, picked up his second goal of the game when he curled around the opposing cage and tucked in a wrap-around goal to extend the lead to 2-0 at 3:48.
With the primary assist on the score, Jonathan Huberdeau earned his 500th career point.
"I got drafted here and it's been quite a ride," said Huberdeau, who is in his 10th season with the Panthers after being drafted third-overall in 2011. "Obviously, it's fun to get 500. Hopefully I have way more [goals] ahead of me. It's just good to see the guys and the support we have."
Appearing to cut their deficit in half, the Islanders thought they'd finally got on the board at 8:06 when Ryan Pulock fired a long shot into an empty net. The reason the net was left unattended, however, was because of the fact Bobrovsky had been pulled out of the crease by Anders Lee.
After the Panthers challenged the play, the goal was overturned for goaltender interference.
"You've got to be more than right when you challenge it, and I thought that was pretty clear," Quenneville said.
Not long after escaping that brush with danger, the Panthers padded their lead further heading into the second intermission when Anthony Duclair settled down a lengthy outlet pass from MacKenzie Weegar and beat Sorokin on a breakaway with a nice deke to make it 3-0 at 18:57.
With the Panthers whistled for a delay of game penalty in the third period, Bobrovsky surrendered his only goal of the contest when Oliver Wahlstrom scored on the power play to cut New York's deficit down to 3-1 at 3:30.
"I saw the puck well," Bobrovsky said. "There were a couple drives, and the guys did a great job on the PK to keep all those shots outside. It's a good team effort and good two points for us."
Shutting down any hopes of a potential late comeback for the Islanders, Bennett ushered in a storm of rats and caps flying toward the ice when he beat Sorokin with a top-shelf snipe from the high slot to complete his impressive hat trick and send the Panthers ahead 4-1 at 9:39.
Adding one more for good measure, Aleksander Barkov then made it 5-1 at 12:22.
"No matter what line we put on the ice, the objective is play offense, keep the puck, play in their end and generate," Quenneville said. "Any line can score on any given night. Our power play hasn't clicked in yet, and I think that is an area where we can improve our offense and our possession game, but we're not complaining. I thought we did a lot of good things tonight."
Off to a perfect 2-0-0 start, the Panthers will now prepare for their toughest test yet.
After facing off in three straight games during the preseason earlier this month, they'll now take on the back-to-back Stanley Cup champion Lightning in a game where the points actually count when the cross-state rivals meet for a highly-anticipated matchup at Amalie Arena on Tuesday.
"We're just going to keep it rolling," Bennett said.
Here are five takeaways from Saturday's win in Sunrise…