"Even some of the games we're losing, we're right in there until the end," Vatrano said. "We're competing every single night. You can't ask more of us. We've just got to keep this thing going."
Heading home after picking up eight of a possible 10 points on their five-game road trip, the Panthers currently sit just one point behind the Hurricanes for first place in the Central Division with a record of 17-5-4, which includes an utterly outstanding 10-2-1 mark away from home.
"I think here's a little excitement in our team as far as the approach during games," coach Joel Quenneville said of Florida's never-say-die attitude. "Keep doing the same things and let's stick with it."
Following a scoreless first period in which both teams had more than a few good looks, Oliver Bjorkstrand opened the scoring for the Blue Jackets in the second when he went top-shelf on Sergei Bobrovsky while on a 2-on-1 break to send the Panthers down into a 1-0 hole at 6:00.
Just 4:14 later, Bjorkstrand struck again when he took a pass from Riley Nash from behind the net and one-timed a shot straight into the twine to give Columbus a 2-0 advantage at 10:14.
Cutting the deficit in half with time winding down in the middle frame, Patric Hornqvist finally got the Panthers on the board when he tipped a shot from Gustav Forsling past Elvis Merzlikins and right into the back of the net at 16:50 to make it a 2-1 game going into the second intermission.
Coming out swinging to start the third period, the Blue Jackets then extended their lead to 3-1 when Patrik Laine buried a booming slap shot on the power play at 3:23. Soon after, Max Domi then pushed the advantage to 4-1 when he kept the puck on a 2-on-1 break and scored at 4:43.
Bobrovsky finished with 28 saves, while Merzlikins stopped 27 of 32 shots.
Not going down without a fight, the Panthers struck back a bit later when Ryan Lomberg - who might also have a shot at making the Opening Day lineup for the Marlins - batted a puck out of the air and past Merzlikins for the first NHL goal of his career to quickly make it a 4-2 game at 6:34.
Bringing the Cats within a goal, Owen Tippett then sniped home a shot at 12:21 to make it 4-3.
"You can see when you get one [goal] there's a little energy on the bench," Tippett said. "Then another one comes, and you have all the momentum. You just have to keep playing the same way."
Taking that momentum and running with it, Aleksander Barkov then finished off a beautiful passing sequence on the power play when he blasted home a heavy one-timer to get the game knotted at 4-4 with just 5:34 remaining in regulation and eventually get the game to overtime.
In the extra frame, the Panthers came oh-so-close on a few great looks before Aaron Ekblad made a nice pass off the boards to send Vatrano and Jonathan Huberdeau up ice on a 2-on-1 break. Shooting for a rebound, Huberdeau then sent the puck off Merzlikin's pads and right onto the stick of Vatrano, who cashed in at 2:48 to complete the comeback and lock in a 5-4 victory.
"We knew we had the momentum going into overtime," Vatrano said. "Hags [Carter Verhaeghe] had a great chance before, and I would've lost some sleep if I didn't bury that second one there. A great play all the way around. Ekkie made a great play up, and Huby was shooting for a purpose off the pad there. It was a great play."
Here are five takeaways from Thursday's win in Columbus…