Each team had different views of the play, which came with the score tied 2-2 and 5:00 remaining in regulation. Carolina appeared to have all the momentum after erasing a 2-0 deficit in the third period with goals from Logan Stankoven at 10:20 and Mark Jankowski at 12:46.
Vegas had a great chance to retake the lead, though, after Barbashev stole the puck from Carolina defenseman Jaccob Slavin in the slot and snapped off a quick shot that Andersen stopped with his blocker.
Barbashev picked up the rebound at the left side of the net, circled behind it and out the other side for a wraparound attempt. Andersen dove in desperation to his left to stop the puck with his stick paddle. With Slavin crawling back to try to help him, Andersen stopped Barbashev’s second effort with his stick paddle, too, and then tried to gather the puck under his glove.
Hurricanes center Jordan Staal fell on top of Andersen while Barbashev made one final attempt, digging in under Andersen’s glove with his stick to knock the puck over the goal line. Referee Jean Hebert immediately waved his arms to signal no goal, though.
“The ruling on the play was goaltender interference,” NHL senior vice president and director of officiating Stephen Walkom told a pool reporter. “He waved it (off) immediately. He believed that it was under the goalie and the Vegas player went after the puck and interfered with the goalie and his ability to freeze the puck and waved it off immediately.”
Still, Golden Knights coach John Tortorella decided to challenge the call that there was no goalie interference.
“I saw a loose puck in front of Freddie,” Tortorella said. “Our player stabbed it, didn’t move the goalie and it goes through into the other side. I’d challenge it 10 out of 10 times”
While the referees reviewed the video, a potential two-goal swing hung in the balance. If Tortorella’s challenge was successful, Vegas would have a 3-2 lead with 5:00 remaining. If the call on the ice was upheld, Vegas would be charged a delay of game penalty for the failed challenge and Carolina would get a chance to take the lead on the power play.
“When I was there, it looked like Freddie just kind of grabbed it and I heard a whistle and all the things,” Staal said. “To me, it felt like a no goal. Obviously, I’m on the other side of it. I’m sure they have a different opinion, but my gut was like, ‘Man, there’s no way.’”
After Hebert and fellow referee Garrett Rank reviewed the video, they upheld the original call of no goal. The score remained tied 2-2 and the Hurricanes went on the power play. Barbashev and some of the other Golden Knights shook their heads in disagreement.
“Yeah, that’s kind of out of our control,” Golden Knights defenseman Noah Hanifin said. “That’s their decision. What are you doing to do about it?”