"They really did set the tone for our team, playing the right way," Panthers coach Joel Quenneville said of the line. "I think that's the one thing about transitioning a defenseman to forward, you know they know how to keep themselves in the play, they're good in the puck areas and they keep it simple."
Dressing eight defensemen, the Panthers went down 1-0 early when Jack Hughes beat Sam Montembeault on the power play at 3:15. But, later in the opening frame, Brett Connolly swung momentum back in Florida's favor when he beat Louie Domingue to tie the game 1-1 at 11:50.
At 19:14, Matheson buried a rebound to put the Panthers up 2-1.
In the second period, it was the fourth line doing the damage once again, as Pysyk took a pass from Matheson and re-directed the puck into the cage to increase the lead to 3-1 at 2:43. Noel Acciari, who was centering the duo, picked up an assist on both Matheson and Pysyk's goals.
"It all worked out or us," Acciari said. "I was the honorary D out there tonight."
After Kevin Rooney cut New Jersey's deficit to 3-2 with a goal at 4:17, Frank Vatrano responded less than a minute later for the Panthers with a long snipe that made it 4-2 at 4:59. Padding the lead further soon after that, Acciari increased the advantage to 5-2 with a rebound goal at 5:38.
Of course, Matheson and Pysyk assisted on Acciari's tally.
"Back to back to back, they all scored a goal, which is unbelievable," Quenneville said.
With 5:30 left in the middle frame, Kyle Palmieri scored on a breakaway to make it 5-3.
While Domingue surrendered five goals on 29 shots, Montembeault looked sharp in just his first start and third appearance with Florida since Nov. 24. Improving to 5-2-1, the 23-year-old rookie made nine high-danger stops, including a huge pad save on Hughes late in the second period.