Anaheim scored three unanswered in the second frame, with Getzlaf prompting the comeback.
His first goal of two came just 1:37 into the middle period. Anaheim's captain corralled the puck at the top of the left circle and fired a wrist shot blocker side on Talbot. As the shot was coming towards the netminder, Corey Perry's skate collided with Talbot's right skate. McLellan used his coach's challenge on the play, looking for a goalie interference call. The call on the ice would stand, however, with Getzlaf scoring his sixth of the post-season. Brandon Montour recorded the only assist for his fourth point of the playoffs.
"I try to play with integrity, not flop and dive, and I don't get the call," said Talbot. "I don't know what else to do on that one - he clearly hits my blocker and my pad."
Rickard Rakell scored the Ducks' second of the game to even things up at 2-2. Letestu broke up the cycle behind the Oilers net, but the puck squirted out to Getzlaf at the post. He made a quick pass to Rakell who swiftly sent it past Talbot at 5:33.
Getzlaf scored after Sami Vatanen fed Rakell in the slot, releasing a one-timer that Talbot was able to kick out. The puck fell on Ryan Nugent-Hopkins' stick but just before he could clear it to safety, Getzlaf chopped at his blade. The hack surprised Talbot and beat him, giving Getzlaf his third point of the night and the Ducks a 3-2 lead.
The Oilers pushed back throughout the third period - outshooting Anaheim 11-7 - but wouldn't be rewarded for their play until under two minutes remained. With the Oilers net empty and following a power play, Caggiula took space in front of the Ducks' net and was able to whack a rebound top shelf to send the game into overtime. Nugent-Hopkins and Maroon filed their third and fourth assists of the post-season on the play, respectively.
Just 45 seconds into overtime, Silfverberg was wide open on Talbot's right side. He received a pass from Getzlaf and wired a shot to win the game.
"We come to practice tomorrow and we put together a plan for Game 3," said McLellan. "It's tied 2-2 with two great teams playing pretty hard hockey. We'll get back at it."
Game 5 will be played Friday night in Anaheim. The puck drops at 8:30 PM MDT.