"It was a great game," Panthers goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky said. "That was a big point for us."
Opening up their scoring in their own barn, the Penguins jumped out to an early lead when Kris Letang skated just below the goal line before setting up Teddy Blueger for an uncontested one-timer in the low slot that flew straight into the back of the cage to make it a 1-0 game at 13:37.
Looking like a player well beyond his age, rookie Anton Lundell then helped even up the score for the Panthers soon after when he finessed his way through the neutral zone to set up a 2-on-1 rush with Frank Vatrano, who finished off the sequence with a goal to make it 1-1 at 16:55.
Despite the Panthers owning a 13-9 advantage in scoring chances in the second period, the Penguins netted the lone goal in the middle frame when Evan Rodrigues skated straight down the slot from the blue line on a breakaway and beat Bobrovsky to make it a 2-1 contest at 17:53.
Getting that goal back, Aleksander Barkov, who has tallied seven goals in his last six games, took a pass from Carter Verhaeghe, who was deftly dancing around the offensive zone with the puck, and ripped a shot past Tristan Jarry to make it a 2-2 game just 2:30 into the third period.
With 4:45 left in regulation, the Panthers appeared to take the lead when Verhaeghe set up Anthony Duclair with a nice pass for a goal on the doorstep, but the score was taken off the board after the Penguins challenged the play and it was eventually ruled offside by officials.
"It was just a little unfortunate, but I don't think it was deflating," Verhaeghe said of the overturned call. "In the third period we liked the way we were playing, and we got one back. We tied the game pretty late there. We liked the way were playing and just tried to keep it going."
From there, the game eventually went to overtime.
In the extra frame, both teams had their fair share of looks before the Panthers were sent to the power play after Jake Guentzel crashed into Bobrovsky and was whistled for interference. But even with 1:31 of a 4-on-3 advantage to work with, they couldn't find a goal before the buzzer.
Once in the shootout, Bryan Rust and Jeff Carter each scored to lift the Penguins to a 3-2 win.
"I thought in the third we really beared down, and got things deep and did the right things," Panthers Interim Head Coach Andrew Brunette said. "We were rewarded [in the third]. We carried a lot of the play for parts of the game. Again, we've got some areas to clean up still."
With the win, the Penguins improved to 5-3-4.
Here are five takeaways from Thursday's loss in Pittsburgh…