"I'm just trying to close my eyes, shoot the puck and hope it goes in," Vatrano smiled.
Extending their point streak to seven games (6-0-1) and improving to 41-13-6, the Panthers sit in first place in the Atlantic Division and have built up a six-point cushion over the Lightning in second place.
"We always find a way to win hockey games," Vatrano said. "We just stick to the game plan."
Already on a 5-on-4 power play in the first period, the Sharks essentially gained a 5-on-3 advantage when Gustav Forsling took a shot off the inside of his left knee and couldn't get off the ice. With play continuing, Logan Couture then tipped in a shot past Spencer Knight to make it a 1-0 game at 8:19.
With the Sharks on the power play again soon after, Jonathan Huberdeau answered for the Panthers when he skated in on a 2-on-1 rush with Sam Bennett and, resisting the urge to pass, lifted a silky wrist shot over Reimer's glove and into the top corner of the cage to even things up and make it 1-1 at 11:21.
At 13:58, Nicolas Meloche wired a shot past Knight to put the Sharks on top 2-1.
On the penalty kill a lot during the second period, the Panthers successfully killed off three power plays for the Sharks, including an extended period of 5-on-3 in which Knight, who turned aside all 12 shots he faced in the middle frame, made several highlight-reel stops on shots from right around the blue paint.
Knight went on to finish with 24 saves on 26 shots, while Reimer gave up three goals on 34 shots.
Coming out flying in the third period, the Panthers pulled even with the Sharks when Vatrano teed up a pass from Noel Acciari, who made a great play to keep the puck in the offensive zone, and fired a heavy shot from the slot that clipped off the post and in with an audibly-pleasing ping to make it 2-2 at 3:29.
Later in the period, Mason Marchment appeared to give the Panthers the lead when he crashed the net and slipped the puck under Reimer's pads and across the goal line. However, the Sharks challenged the score, which was eventually overturned for goaltender interference upon further review by the officials.
After hitting a few more posts and coming oh-so-close to finding the go-ahead goal later in regulation, the Panthers eventually took the game to overtime where, following a faceoff win from Sam Reinhart in the offensive zone, Vatrano one-timed a pass from Forsling past Reimer at 1:11 to lock in the 3-2 victory.