Oliver Bjorkstrand extended the lead to 2-0 at 2:23 of the third period with an unassisted goal. He scored after intercepting a pass by Stars forward Joel Kiviranta in the slot.
"That's what you want. I'll take that any day," Bjorkstrand said of the turnover.
Said Kiviranta, "We need to play better defense, and the way we're playing at this point of the season right now, I feel sad to make plays and mistakes like that."
Stars coach Rick Bowness said miscues are going to happen with the roster they have.
"Well, he's a kid, he made a mistake," Bowness said of the 24-year-old rookie forward. "We said earlier in the year, we're going to play the kids and we're going to have to live with the mistakes.
"That's what comes when you play a lot of young players. They're going to make some mistakes, and they've got to know that if they make a mistake, they're going to go right back out. If they continue to make mistakes, they're going to lose ice time."
After Robinson scored when Jenner's shot went in off his skate, Miro Heiskanen cut the Columbus lead to 3-1 at 7:35 with Dallas' first goal in 189:46. He took a pass from Jamie Benn and scored from above the right face-off circle for his first goal of the season.