But in the first Stanley Cup Playoff game in their history, they had a chance to win a physical, tight-checking battle on the road against a team with a history of postseason success.
“There’s no reason for us to be down on ourselves right now,” forward Lawson Crouse said.
There’s reason to believe. Game 2 of the best-of-7 series is here Tuesday (9:30 p.m. ET; Utah16, SCRIPPS, ESPN2, TVAS2, SN, CBC).
“From now on, it’s a race of improvement,” coach Andre Tourigny said. “We have stuff we can be better at, and we’ll make some adjustments. But I’m really proud of the way we performed.”
The Mammoth entered Game 1 as the underdogs.
While this was their first playoff game since the NHL Board of Governors approved a new franchise in Utah on April 18, 2024, this was the Golden Knights’ 107th since they entered the NHL as an expansion team in 2017-18.
Vegas had almost exactly double (1,225 games) the amount of playoff experience on its roster than Utah (612) did. The Golden Knights had won 62 games and 12 series in the playoffs -- and the Stanley Cup in 2023.
That said, in the regular season, the Mammoth (92), the first wild card in the West, were three points behind the Golden Knights (95), the Pacific Division champions. Since entering the League last season, they had gone 3-2-1 against them, including 2-0-1 at T-Mobile Arena.
In the rearview mirror, they were closer than they appeared.
The Mammoth looked like they belonged from puck drop, generating scoring chances, standing up for themselves in scrums.
One of seven players making his NHL playoff debut, forward Logan Cooley scored the first playoff goal in Utah history with a one-timer from the right circle with 11 seconds left in the first period, giving the Mammoth a 1-0 lead.
After forward Colton Sissons scored for Vegas to tie it 1-1 at 3:44 of the second period, forward Kevin Stenlund gave Utah a 2-1 lead with a lucky goal at 5:07. Defenseman Sean Durzi rimmed the puck around the boards, and goalie Carter Hart couldn’t corral it. Stenlund threw it at the net from the right wing. It went off Hart’s stick, off defenseman Kaedan Korczak and into the net.