"He's got all the tools and the size," Central Scouting's Al Jensen said. "He's got calmness and that positive swagger as well. I watched him in warmups, was impressed by the way he handles the puck on his stick. He held his ground when facing good chances, stayed patient on a few dekes. He challenges and tracks pucks well and has a good feel for the game. This kid is good."
Phantoms coach Ryan Ward said he and his staff did a lot of work recruiting Trejbal, who is represented by the same agency as former Youngstown center Adam Benak, a fourth-round pick (No. 102) of the Minnesota Wild in the 2025 NHL Draft. The Phantoms run a hockey camp in Czechia every summer and Ward was confident after watching Trejbal that he'd be able to step right in as a legitimate No. 1 starter.
"He has developed an unflappability to his game," Ward said. When he gets scored on, it's next-puck mentality. He's just matured into an NHL caliber goalie as far as mindset goes and I think whenever players come over here from Europe and play in North America, it's an adjustment. It's obviously an adjustment being away from home in a different country and I feel like Tobias has handled that extremely well with a ton of maturity."
Trejbal is 28-9-3 with a 2.15 GAA, .916 save percentage and three shutouts in 40 games as a USHL rookie. Committed to the University of Massachusetts in 2026-27, he ranks eighth in shots faced (1,018) and seventh for fewest goals allowed (86) this season.
"I committed to UMass in 2024, so that was kind of the reason I decided to spend a season in the USHL ... to get a feel of USA Hockey," Trejbal said.
Ward does see traits in his goalie he feels will translate well at the next level.
"I think that very seldom does 'Toby' lose his net; he's extremely athletic, extremely competitive, but the mental game that he has is an NHL caliber mentality," Ward said. "Second, he's big, he's technical and he's athletic. Those are all things that you see in the best goalies in the National Hockey League. I firmly believe this kid is a No. 1 at the NHL level at some point in his career. When he's in net, there's a confidence that comes over our team, our coaching staff. You always feel like you have a chance to win the game.
"I think the last goalie that I kind of felt like that about was (Montreal Canadiens goalie) Jacob Fowler (who played two seasons at Youngstown from 2021-23). Jacob is doing a great job, obviously, in the NHL, and I think Toby's a lot like him."