It's how Sullivan envisioned the Rangers playing last season, too. But they got off to a slow start, it derailed from there, and then defenseman Adam Fox and Shesterkin sustained long-term injuries in the same game (Jan. 5 against the Utah Mammoth).
Soon after, the Rangers announced they would be sellers ahead of the NHL Trade Deadline.
"Last year, obviously, I wouldn't say anyone was happy with how that went," Fox said. "This year, definitely, I think we've played well all year. Obviously, you're not going to win every game, but the identity of our team is defending, being hard to play against, making it hard for other teams to create offense and showcase their skills."
The Rangers are sixth in goals-against per game (2.64), first on the penalty kill (89.7 percent), 10th in shots on goal against per game (26.4) and 11-1-0 in games when they have scored the first goal.
“‘Sully' always says that statistically our best games offensively come from when we're playing our best defensively," Miller said. "Very rarely do we play the track meet game. That's what our brand is."
The principles of their defensive game have been essential to their success since Shesterkin got hurt.
No longer could the Rangers rely on a goalie who was making a career out of bailing out a team that was known to be too careless in the defensive zone, stubbornly east-west through the middle of the ice.
"I don't think there was an adjustment," Sullivan said. "I just think it's a heightened priority."
Coupling that devastating blow was the fact that backup goalie Joonas Korpisalo was also out with a foot infection.
The Rangers were left with rookie Dylan Garand, who was waived prior to the start of the season, as their new No. 1 for most of the first quarter.
Garand delivered in his first two starts after Shesterkin's injury, but then the Rangers went into a mini-tailspin, losing six of seven (1-5-1) and allowing 4.57 goals per game between Oct. 15-Nov. 1.
It wasn't because of goaltending, though it's foolish to think Shesterkin wouldn't have helped stop some of that bleeding.
"We were slow to react," Miller said. "It was like, 'OK, let's go,' versus, 'I'm (bleeping) going.' There's a big difference.
"It's easy to say that with new goalies coming in we went into a bad stretch of hockey, but we weren't playing our style. We weren't quick to play defense. We didn't check fast.
"It was a good test for us to go through some adversity in that last stretch and come back and basically wash it out by playing the way we have."
They've outscored their opponents 22-12 in the past seven games, with the lone blemish a 3-1 loss in Edmonton on Nov. 9.
Garand has delivered in his past four starts with a 1.51 goals-against average and .943 save percentage (six goals on 105 shots). Korpisalo has been nearly perfect since re-joining the lineup in Seattle on Nov. 7, winning his three starts with a 1.67 GAA and .940 save percentage.
"For me it goes back to what does Rangers hockey look like when it's at its best," Sullivan said. "That's the question I always ask our group. What do we want it to look like? Now let's build an action plan to get there.
"We check hard. We defend hard. And we have the ability to score goals off of that."