Lafreniere scored his second goal of the game into an empty net at 18:22 of the third period to make it 4-2 and added another empty-net goal at 18:54 for the 5-2 final.
"We're using him 5-on-6; that's a responsibility, that's a privilege, but we think he's a guy that's very capable there," Rangers coach Mike Sullivan said. "So we're challenging him to bring a defensive conscience in those situations and he gets rewarded with empty-net opportunities."
Bjorkstrand gave the Rangers a 1-0 lead at 6:40 of the first period.
Lafreniere won the puck from Matthew Schaefer along the end boards in the Islanders zone with a strong forecheck. He moved it into the right face-off circle, and Bjorkstrand scored on the Rangers' first shot on goal of the game, a one-timer over Varlamov's left shoulder.
Lafreniere scored 25 seconds into the second period to extend the lead to 2-0. Zibanejad, from his knees in the defensive zone, hit Lafreniere with a stretch pass into the neutral zone. Lafreniere got into the left circle and scored with a far-side shot.
"Just trying to get it to 'Laffy,' " Zibanejad said. "I saw 'Laffy' take off. Just happy I didn't turn it over. That was a nice shot by him."
The Islanders, though, tied it in the second.
Horvat made it 2-1 with a power-play goal at 2:56. He beat Shesterkin with a one-timer from the left circle off a pass from Matias Maccelli.
Ritchie tied it 2-2 at 4:52.
"We had a chance to take the lead; that maybe changes the game," Islanders coach Peter DeBoer said. "I thought we had at least two good looks when it was 2-2 to get in front for the first time all night, and we didn't take advantage. And then, obviously, that power-play goal, again, playing from behind. It's not easy in this league playing from behind."
NOTES: Rangers center Cole Beaudoin played 9:57 and was plus-1 with three hits in his NHL debut. The 20-year-old was recalled from Hartford of the American Hockey League on Tuesday to replace Joe Veleno, who is out with a lower-body injury. … .Islanders defenseman Alexander Romanov sustained an undisclosed injury in the third period. There was no update after the game. ... For the first time in the Rangers-Islanders rivalry, both teams had a teenage defenseman in their lineup. Rangers defenseman Alberts Smits (18 years, 308 days) is the youngest defenseman in the NHL, and Schaefer (19 years, 31 days) is the second youngest.