Shortly after the first penalty had expired on a 5-on-3 power play, the Jets would take the lead on a highlight reel worthy passing play.
Scheifele gained the zone, then sent a quick pass forward to Mathieu Perreault, who sent a short one-touch drop pass back to Laine who had joined the rush. With Reimer playing Laine's shot, the Finn sent a cross ice pass to Wheeler on Reimer's right side, and the captain made no mistake, sending a wrist shot top corner to make it 3-2.
It was the only power play marker the Jets would get on the seven opportunities they had.
"That was a great chance to score. I had an empty net myself, and just couldn't score," said Laine. "But those are the chances you have to score. Late in the game, chasing one goal, and a 5-on-3, you just have to score."
Florida tied things up when the Jets got hemmed in their zone, and Colton Sceviour slid a backhand pass from below the goal line out front to Denis Malgin. His quick release got by Comrie on the glove side.
Vincent Trochek put the Panthers back in front on the power play in the opening minute of the third period. With Blake Wheeler off for high-sticking, Trochek was right outside the crease to chip home the rebound after Comrie made the initial save off a deflected point shot.
The see-saw battle continued after the Florida goal, as Patrik Laine squeezed his 14th of the season under the arm of Reimer with a quick wrist shot from his off wing just 63 seconds after Florida took the lead.
Michael Haley put the Panthers back in front for good, when he deflected a Derek MacKenzie's point shot in the slot past Comrie.
Trochek would add an empty net goal to round out the scoring.
"We had enough opportunities to score goals and finish on plays that we didn't get to the net," said Maurice. "I think we missed the net 18 times. Just a little too loose on our coverage. We've given up 10 hockey goals in the last two games. We're going to have to play a little bit of a tighter game than that."
The Jets wrap up the three-game Eastern Conference road trip on Saturday against the NHL's top team, the Tampa Bay Lightning.