So far, he has handled every tough situation. On Thursday, the Stars were coming off a four-game road trip and facing a Washington team with one of the greatest scorers in NHL history, Alex Ovechkin. Oettinger stopped seven shots from Ovechkin, including a couple of huge blasts.
"Get big and hope it hits you," he said of his strategy. "Every game is an opportunity to make a big save, and thankfully I was able to do that tonight."
And if he does that, the team and the coaching staff get more and more confidence.
"He's got a great demeanor," DeBoer said. "He's very professional but also has a real calming personality. He doesn't get too high or too low. What gets overlooked sometimes is that the guys have to want to play for you. They have to want to throw themselves in front of a puck to help you out because you're a good guy and a good teammate. He's got all of those qualities."
Oettinger knew the pressure would be there after the playoffs, but it was more motivating than scary.
"You've seen goalies in the past go on crazy runs and not be able to sustain a great career," he said. "If I do what I do every day and do all of the little things continually, I'm going to like my game and play well for a long time hopefully.
And building up his shutout numbers is a nice fringe benefit.
"Those are really hard to come by in this league, and it takes a full team effort," he said of the shutout. "A ton of guys did a ton of things for me tonight, and our PK has been unreal this whole season. I owe a lot of guys thanks for tonight."
The Stars had a great team effort in front of their goalie. Missing Miro Heiskanen for the second game because of an upper body injury, Dallas received strong play from the entire group of defensemen. Nils Ludkvist had a hard shot that Jason Robertson tipped in for the first goal, and five different defensemen played more than 19 minutes.