Nick Cousins, Alex Galchenyuk and Vinnie Hinostroza all scored goals on Florida goalie Roberto Luongo in the shootout. Darcy Kuemper, who made 24 saves in 65 minutes, stopped one of the two shootout shots he faced.
Stepan and Oliver Ekman-Larsson produced goals 11:00 apart in the second, and Arizona led 2-1 after 40 minutes. But Florida notched two goals in the third period to take a 3-2 lead, and then headed to a power play when Brad Richardson was called for hooking with 6:46 to play. Just 17 seconds into the penalty kill, Stepan tied the score after making a nifty toe drag around Panthers defender Keith Yandle.
"The defenseman came sliding at me quicker than I thought he was going to," Stepan said. "My original thought was to try to get it over to (Richard Panik), but he came over and I decided to try to get around him."
Both goalies were solid in net in the overtime, when the teams combined for 13 shots in five minutes. Ekman-Larsson even made a nice 'save' to keep the game going.
"I thought that we stuck with it, and we've seen it so many times this year," Ekman-Larsson said. "We never give up. We just keep playing and keep finding ways to win hockey games now, and that's what it's all about."
Head Coach Rick Tocchet liked how the Coyotes competed 48 hours after an emotional win over Winnipeg and the Shane Doan jersey retirement ceremony. There was no hangover, he said.
"I thought we played a good game," Tocchet said. "It was back and forth all night and you could see on the bench we picked it up. It's been that way all year. When we're down, we're embracing those moments ... I think the guys are believing in what we're doing, they're pulling for each other ... We have 19 games left and it's going to have to be like this from here on in."