After a slow start, Trotz shuffled his lines in the second period, flip-flopping Eberle and Josh Bailey on the top two lines.
The re-jiggered lines accomplished their goal, as the Islanders scored a pair of goals 4:15 apart to notch the score 2-2 just past the midway mark of the frame.
Eberle, playing with Brock Nelson and Leo Komarov, put the Islanders on the board at 7:31, one-timing a feed from Adam Pelech past Carter Hart. Pelech made the play happen with a good pinch off the blue line, circling the net before spotting and feeding Eberle.
"I thought Jordan was going pretty good on that [Barzal] line the last couple of games, but just not getting results," Trotz said. "When he jumped on that [Nelson] line, I thought he was good. What I liked about him - it wasn't a demotion, I had to get some of our lines going here - he took it upon himself to say, 'Hey I'll make a difference.' That's what you want from your veterans. If you move them around, they can bring other guys with them. I thought Jordan did that tonight, that's really good on him."
Mayfield tied the score with his first of the season shortly after, beating Hart with a half-slapper from the top of the right circle at 11:46. Mayfield's goal capped some good pressure by the Islanders new-look line that saw Josh Bailey up with Mat Barzal and Anders Lee.
"It's just trying to find something different," Eberle said. "We have a lot of guys who can play in a lot of different places. It kickstarted us a bit and we started to play well. [Bailey] and myself, we're fine wherever. We're both here to win hockey games, we don't care where we are."