Although Stern shortchanged himself a little bit, he ended up finishing with 10, hitting double-digits for the second straight season, he was not exactly known for scoring in bunches.
"For someone like myself, getting a hat-trick in the NHL was a pretty big feat," Stern said. "Pretty exciting when you score as few goals as I did."
But as thrilling as it was for Stern, by the time he completed the hat-trick, it was 12-1 for the Flames late in the third period.
"You're still excited, but you also understand that you can't rub it in, and you can't celebrate too much," he said. "There are some guys out there who could take liberties, so you're definitely not trying to celebrate too much and be respectful."
Although the Flames still had a job to do, Reese recalls thinking along the same lines. "You're just trying to get through the game without getting injured," the former netminder said. "Players are thinking about just getting through the next one."
When the final buzzer sounded, and both Reese and Stern emerged unscathed, reality set in for the goaltender. He hadn't realized he had made history.
"Certainly didn't think it was a record," he said. "Thought Grant Fuhr or Billy Smith would have had it, so it was a really special thing."
Although Reese was proud of the way he played on both sides of the puck, he felt bad for his colleagues at the other end of the ice.
After Arturs Irbe gave up seven goals just over the halfway mark of the second period, the Latvian netminder was replaced by Jeff Hackett, who Reese trained with during the offseason.
Years later, when Irbe and Reese were honing their skills as goalie coaches, they met each other for the first time.
"The first thing Irbe said was 'I remember you. I remember that night,'" Reese said with a chuckle.
Stern became even more acquainted with the Sharks, signing as a free agent in San Jose in 1998, but by the time he got there, there was nobody remaining on the roster who had endured the drubbing.
Three decades later, the thing that still sticks out the most for Reese from that game is his astonishment that he still holds the league record for the most points in a game by a goalie.
"It still surprises me," he said. "The way the guys handle the puck now, it's just a dimension in your game."