The incredible display of hand-eye coordination gave Minnesota a 1-0 lead and was Spurgeon's fifth goal in the past 12 games.
Minnesota has now converted on at least one power play chance in 12 of the past 15 games.
Unfortunately for the Wild, it was unable to get more than one goal in a period that ended up being its best one of the night.
"That's what usually happens if you don't capitalize on the opportunities when you out play a team in a period," said Wild coach Bruce Boudreau. "You are supposed to do that. I blame myself for putting some of the wrong guys out and the wrong time. We will watch some video tomorrow. Hopefully we learn from it."
2. Jason Zucker gave himself a belated birthday present by scoring on a pretty backhander midway through the second period.
After an outstanding outlet pass by Mikael Granlund sprung Zucker on his offhand down the right-wing boards, the now 25-year-old winger flew past two Devils and flipped a backhand shot inside the far post for his 12th goal of the season.
Granlund now has an assist in four straight games, with five helpers over that span. Koivu, who earned the second assist on Spurgeon's goal, also had an assist on Zucker's tally for his 78th career multi-assist game.
Koivu is averaging a point per game in the past 26 games dating back to Nov. 21 (11-15=26).
3. Erik Haula snapped an eight-game goal drought in the third period.
The tally, his seventh, gave the Wild a brief 3-2 lead in the third period before New Jersey (19-18-9) netted two late to take home the win. Haula's goal was also the second of the night knocked out of midair and into the back of the net.
With oodles of traffic in front of Schneider, Spurgeon's shot from the left point hit Coyle in front of the goal, allowing Haula to take a backhanded whack at the puck. Schneider, not expecting the quick shot, was helpless in his crease.
Spurgeon earned an assist for his 22nd multi-point game in the NHL.
Just 22 seconds after Haula's goal, Kyle Palmieri tied the game at 3-3 before Beau Bennett's winner with 2:17 remaining.
"It's frustrating because we threw it away," said Wild goaltender Devan Dubnyk. "We haven't done that. We talked about this is an important game for us. Tie game with two minutes left, that's where we're usually solid."