But the Stars got in penalty trouble later in the period and gave the Devils some life, taking three straight penalties including a cross-checking minor by Klingberg and a questionable high-sticking double minor on Johns. The Stars almost got through it, but Boyle scored with nine seconds left on the third penalty to put New Jersey up 3-2.
The goal was followed by a heated exchange between Boyle and Klingberg, whose cross-check on Boyle started the penalty sequence. Stars defenseman Greg Pateryn jumped into the fray, and Boyle and Pateryn both ended up with minor penalties, and Boyle got tagged with an extra 10-minute misconduct.
"I told him he's 100 pounds heavier than me and I thought he fell easy there," Klingberg said of the exchange with Boyle. "I don't think it's a cross-check. And then after that goal, he [celebrated] in my face and I don't think that was respectful, but he said he was sorry, so let's move on."
There was another scrum at the end of the second, and Zacha picked up the only minor in that one, putting the Stars on a power play to open the third. New Jersey took another penalty early in the third, putting the Stars on a five-on-three power play for 53 seconds. The Stars couldn't cash in but had two great point-blank chances by Radulov, who hit the post on one and was denied by Schneider on the other.
"It was a designed play, and we pulled it off twice. He made a save on one, and we hit the goalpost on the other," said Hitchcock.
The Devils extended the lead to 4-2 at 12:57 of the third period, pinning the Stars in their end of the ice and Nick Lappin scoring off a rebound.
The Stars pulled Lehtonen with just under four minutes remaining for an extra attacker and Benn had a great chance to cut the lead to one, but Schneider came up with a great stop to keep it a 4-2 game. Boyle scored into the empty net with 2:00 remaining to make it a 5-2 final.