Things went awry early for the Caps on Monday. Seconds after Caps goalie Braden Holtby made a toe save with the full extension of his left leg at the right post, the Stars scored anyway on the other side of the net, and there was nothing Holtby could do about it.
Brooks Orpik checked Stars forward Devin Shore into the crease, but once there, Shore put down roots and began building a house while Patrick Sharp retrieved the puck and pulled it around to the other side. With Shore firmly planted in the crease, Holtby could not slide across to the left post, and Sharp tapped it to the front where Shore jammed it in at 1:48 of the first period.
The Caps quickly issued a coach's challenge alleging goaltender interference, but the officials ruled that the goal would count because "the attacking Player was pushed, shoved or fouled by a defending Player causing the attacking Player to come into contact with the goalkeeper." (Italicized portion taken directly from email from NHL Situation Room.)
After some uncharacteristically sloppy moments in their own end of the ice in the immediate aftermath of the Shore goal, the Caps straightened up a bit and earned a pair of first-period power play opportunities against the league's weakest power play unit, statistically speaking. Although the Capitals pounded five shots on goal during the four minutes they spent on the man advantage in the first, they weren't able to get one behind Dallas netminder Kari Lehtonen.
The Stars struck twice early in the second. First, a rare Nicklas Backstrom turnover in front resulted in an unassisted Radek Faksa goal at 4:04. Then, less than two minutes later, Jason Spezza hopped over the boards and blasted a one-timer past Holtby to make it a 3-0 game. At that point, Caps coach Barry Trotz pulled Holtby in favor of Philipp Grubauer. Holtby's 21-game streak without a regulation loss also ended on Monday; it was the second longest streak of its kind in his career and the third longest in team history.