That's a really good question. I believe the Stars were involved in both the John Tavares and Erik Karlsson talks because they were told that the players were interested in Dallas. Now, should we take that as a good sign that both believe the Stars are a good organization and a desirable destination or should we be concerned that neither deal could get done?
I think Tavares was going to Toronto no matter what, and I think the Stars likely had the better offer for Ottawa. But the timeline of the negotiations didn't work out. I think Jim Nill made his best offer right off the bat and Ottawa didn't know what to do with it. Then, when Dallas didn't want to sweeten the offer, Ottawa went elsewhere. But what does all of that mean for how the Stars are being built? Well, there are only so many superstars available and every organization and deal is different, so the Stars aren't going to just be able to jump to the next best player.
I think they are open to a trade and I think Nill is plugged in on just about every available player, so it's definitely a possibility. The Stars currently have about $4 million in cap space for this season and could shed about $10 million more next season (with UFAs leaving and still adding Tyler Seguin's raise), so Dallas has the ability to be in on pretty much any deal it feels would work. I believe they want to trust the younger players, but they also very much want to win now.
My guess is if they are looking like a playoff team, they will be in a lot of conversations to add a player as the season goes along. At the very least, they are positioned to land a big free agent next summer.