This was a game that featured a plethora of head-scratching moments, and at the end of the day, were it not for the power play, which accounted for three of the Stars' four goals, this was a mismatch.
For the third game in a row, the Stars gave up a goal in the final 30 seconds of a period. Sure, the Pat Maroon one with 24.1 seconds left in the first was bad luck, as the puck glanced in off Marc Methot's skate, but sill those are killers.
In short, there were plenty of folks who weren't at their best on this night.
On the Oilers' third goal, Jamie Oleksiak, after being scratched in four of the last five games, went for a big hit in the offensive zone at the hash marks, leaving Antoine Roussel to get back in his place. Nugent-Hopkins scored with Bishop unable to get into the net following a scramble.
John Klingberg, arguably the Stars best defender thus far this season, probably had his worst outing of the season, at one point making a no-look drop pass to an open space with Connor McDavid on the ice, setting up a good chance for arguably the game's best player.
Martin Hanzal, who has struggled to get into a groove thus far this season, bowled over an Oiler defender standing next to the Oiler goal with 2:26 left in the second period. Inexcusable, even if the Stars' penalty kill is rocking right now.
And all in all, a very difficult night for Mattias Janmark, who somehow ended up minus-4. Brett Ritchie was minus-3.
"Well, we clawed back, so you like that part of it, but it's really disappointing," said head coach Ken Hitchcock. "It's really disappointing that we're not doing enough of the details that can control the hockey game. Ice the puck after won face-offs. We were almost 70 percent on the faceoff dot and we got away with it in the first period, and in the third period, it cost us the tying goal. We iced it three times before they finally scored. And then, we just don't do enough in the details in critical ice to have a better record.
"We look like we should have a way better record by the way we play, but in the details, we don't get it done. Not right now."