They insisted after the game the call on Toews didn't take any wind out of their sails, but they strayed from their structure to start the third and gave up a rush that allowed Foegele to score top shelf from the right circle past Robin Lehner for his fifth goal in nine Stanley Cup Playoff games. Niederreiter then gave Carolina the lead for good with a redirection of Teuvo Teravainen's shot through traffic.
"Obviously, I want to save it," said Lehner, who made 16 saves. "I should save it. But you know what? Sometimes the goal goes in. It was still a pretty good shot, but I should definitely save that. But then they got a good tip.
"The reality of the story is they've scored three goals in two games. We're down two. Now we've got to go to their rink and do the same."
Aside from the brief lapse, the Islanders were sharp again in their own zone, limiting the Hurricanes to three shots on goal in the first period, then gave them nothing when Carolina had a 5-on-3 power play for 1:25 early in the second.
They gave themselves every chance to tie the game in the third. Jordan Eberle, who scored in each of New York's four straight wins against the Pittsburgh Penguins in the first round, hit the crossbar with 7:34 remaining. Defenseman Ryan Pulock took a slap shot from the point with 1:02 remaining that also hit the crossbar, and Lee's rebound attempt went off the side of the net.
"Last game, we should've had a goal that we didn't get," Lehner said. "We had a goalie interference, should have been a goal. We've got to fight through that. That's not an excuse. Today, what did we have, three, four posts, bars? Couple ones that were real close to going in. We were the better team today. They got a goal and they got a good tip. It's just unfortunate that we didn't come back."
The difference between being up 2-0, tied 1-1 and the reality, down 0-2, is that slim. But here the Islanders are, in the same position Trotz found himself in with the Capitals a year ago after losing the first two games in the first round at home to the Columbus Blue Jackets. Washington not only rallied to win that series in six games, it went on to win the Stanley Cup.
"Your initial emotion after a game where you feel like you played well enough to win the hockey game and you don't, I think there's some frustration for a few minutes and then I think confidence grows out of that and you go, 'You know what? We're fine. Just play our game and we'll win the series,'" Trotz said. "We dug ourselves a hole. We've been resilient all year.
"We've been good on the road. Obviously, they've got a good home record, they're in the playoffs. Their fans are outstanding like ours were today. We'll go in there and play our best and see if we can get the results that we need."