The memories certainly aren't limited to current goalies.
Canucks goaltending coach Dan Cloutier remembers his favorite gift being a set of red, white and blue DR pads -- "Montreal colors," he said -- at the age of 12.
San Jose goaltending coach Johan Hedberg still owns his favorite present.
"I was the youngest of three brothers so I was forced to play net, but gear obviously became a big part of being a goalie," said Hedberg, from Leksand, Sweden. "I remember one Christmas I got a new catching glove, which is my favorite glove of all time. It was an old CCM glove, it looked like a baseball glove, and it was awesome. It still sits in my attic back home in Sweden."
Hedberg said he was 8 or 9 when he got the glove, and he wore it until he was 13.
"I played with it for way too long," he said. "My hand outgrew it, went right through the stitching at the end of the fingers. Goalie gear is exciting, it's fun. When new stuff comes out on the market, I think every goalie gets excited and I am one of them."
Combine that with the excitement of Christmas, and it's not surprising so many NHL goalies have a favorite gift memory that stands out.