The Islanders got off to a fast start on Saturday outshooting the Blue Jackets 8-1 early, including a freak deflection that put the Isles out in front 1-0. Sam Gagner went to clear the puck out of the Blue Jackets end, but his attempt clipped Bailey's stick, lobbed up and fell down past Sergei Bobrovsky at 5:59.
Things evened out later in the period, as the Blue Jackets benefited from a deflection off an Islanders' stick, as Jack Johnson's point shot caromed off Cal Clutterbuck's lumber and past Halak at 13:39.
Columbus took at 2-1 lead midway through the second period, as Johnson sprung Cam Atkinson for a breakaway that the Blue Jackets' leading scorer converted at 10:16. This time the Islanders responded with a quick goal, as Tavares put in a second effort to get his own rebound and lift it over Bobrovsky's pad in tight.