If there was going to be any repeat-miracle, it had to start happening in the next game in Uniondale, May 7, 1975. If someone had played Frank Sinatra's classic recording of "All Or Nothing At All," it would have summed up the Isles precarious position.
"You'd think that we were up-tight," remembered Glenn Resch, star of the Penguins series. "But we were much looser being down three games. We felt we could repeat it."
The Isles sure looked it, after they established a 3-0 lead. But that disappeared as fast as you can say, "One, Two Three," which comprised the next trio of red lights; all belonging to Philly.
In the final seconds of the third period, the Coliseum crowd gasped as the Flyers hardest shooter, Reggie Leach, fired a bazooka at Resch. It beat Chico, that was for sure, but did it end he game -- and the Islanders.
Not so fast. Referee Dave Newell rushed to linesman Claude Bechard and Leon Stickle. Following their high-level conference they disallowed the goal on the grounds that the puck beat Resch after the final buzzer sounded.
"Given that new life," said Denis Potvin, "we were obligated to do something positive."
And they did; in a hurry. Before the sudden-death period was two minutes old, Jude Drouin scored, sending the headline-writers and reporters rushing to produce new words for the Isles.
Writing in the Daily News, reporter Bill Verigan observed, "The legend of the Islanders grew last night."
A Post headline was no less enthused: YES, THE ISLANDERS BELIEVE.
RELATED: THE TOUGH CORRALLING OF DENIS POTVIN
That pushed the series to a Game Five at The Spectrum on May 8th and, suddenly, the pendulum had swung the Islanders way with a 5-1 win. It was punctuated by some emphatic punches leveled by Clark Gillies against Dave (The Hammer) Schultz.
"Three good punches landed," the huge left wing recalled. "The first one got him near the nose. I had him going pretty good."
Gillies arms were flailing like windmills and when the dust had finally cleared, The Hammer appeared to be a man who once looked like Dave Schultz. As for the Islanders, the Gillies TKO proved that no team -- not even the Bullies -- could push them around with impunity.
On May 11th the miracle-in-the-making had a chance to grow. It was another Game Six in Uniondale and the Arbourmen had trouble explaining this comeback after the one against Pittsburgh.
Denis Potvin: "We were like a guy at Vegas who defies the Law of Probability by main point after point on a bot roll. The stickmen say, 'He's unconscious.' That was our secret."
Sure enough, it carried over into their latest do-or-die game. After Philly took a 1-0 lead before the game was a minute old the Flyers held the edge until Potvin potted one on a late second period power play.