Smitty remained in mint condition as Game Two unfolded in Buffalo on May 1, 1980. In fact many signs suggested that he was hellbent for a shutout. "We had everyone going," Potvin remembered. "We were optimistic about making it two wins in a row."
To do so, they needed Smith to play goal as he never had before. With the score still 0-0 Battlin' Bill showed why he was to be re-named "Mister Clutch." In a pair of rapidly-unfolding plays, he stopped Gil Perreault and then made a diving save on Derek Smith at the left post.
Meanwhile, Butch Goring made his arrival on the Isles look more significant than ever.
With the teams still deadlocked in the second period, the newest Islander blasted a shot through goalie Bob Sauve's arms at 15:02 of the middle frame to put the Isles ahead, 1-0.
But the Sabres would not be denied and at 11:47 of the third period Andre Savard cashed in a Smith rebound to tie the count, 1-1. That sent the combatants to the dressing room to prepare for what was to become -- at that point -- the longest game in the franchise's history.
Based on potential scoring chances, either team could have broken the game open in the first sudden death period but both Sauve and Smith were equal to the goaltending task. Now it was a battle of attrition with fatigue becoming a factor. The fresher team figured to win.
MAVEN'S MEMORIES: HOW BOSSY FELL TO THE ISLES
"Between overtime periods," said Potvin, "we felt we had an edge going into the second OT. We were better conditioned; but we had to go out and show that it would make a difference."
It was just past midnight when the puck was dropped for the second sudden death; a first for both teams. Coach Arbour dispatched two of his most reliable clutch players to, hopefully, dispatch the Sabres from Game Two,.
The Clutch Guys, Gillies and Nystrom -- those hard-nosed Western Canadians -- immediately went to work and put a full-ice press on the Sabres defense like you wouldn't believe. Twice the Buffalo backliners tried to relieve the pressure by clearing their defensive zone.
But Gillies said no. On each Sabres attempt, Clark snared the puck the way he would pull trout out of the Saskatchewan River near his hometown of Moose Jaw.
More desperate than ever, Buffalo sharpshooter Richard Martin finally tried a pressure-releasing icing and this, too, failed, while the Isles tightened the noose.