Luke Hughes then cut it to 4-3 at 18:33 of the first, scoring a power-play goal with a one-timer from above the circles.
Pavel Buchnevich made it 5-3 at 3:55 of the second period. He kept the puck on a 2-on-1, made a move to his forehand in tight, and slid the puck just across the goal line past Allen.
Connor Brown got the Devils to within 5-4 at 4:42. Lombardi stripped Barron of the puck in the right corner, and Rodrigues quickly passed to Brown for a shot from the circle that beat Binnington short side.
Mailloux answered back at 7:40, taking a drop pass from Neighbours on a rush and scoring short side with a wrist shot from the top of the left circle to make it 6-4.
Mason McTavish scored a power-play goal at 8:59, sliding the puck between Allen’s pads while cutting across the net on a partial break to push the lead to 7-4.
Berggren scored on a breakaway of his own at 1:07 of the third period to make it 8-4.
Rodrigues redirected Jonas Siegenthaler's shot from the left point to make it 8-5 at 3:52, and Declan Chisholm cut it to 8-6 with a one-timer from the left circle at 16:41.
Berggren scored an empty-net goal at 17:43 for the 9-6 final.
“That’s exactly what we’re not supposed to do,” Devils captain Nico Hischier said. “Definitely not good at all. The chances we gave up we should never (give up). The whole point of defending is to not give up those chances. It’s just a horrible game defensively.”
NOTES: Neighbours’ first three assists were the third-fastest in NHL history from the start of a game, behind Guy Lafleur (5:37 on March 27, 1979) and Pavol Demitra (5:43 on Nov. 13, 2005). ... Jack Hughes had his 134th career multipoint game, tying Kirk Muller for third in Devils history. ... Thomas recorded his third straight three-point game (two goals, seven assists). He is the first Blues player to get at least three points in three straight games since Keith Tkachuk did it in four straight in 2005-06. ... The Blues defeated the Anaheim Ducks 8-6 here on Tuesday. They are the second team in the past 30 years to score eight or more goals in consecutive home games, joining the Boston Bruins (2011-12).