Snuggerud made it 3-1 at 17:20 with a wrist shot on a rebound after Thomas tipped a shot from Neighbours onto Silovs.
Hofer then made three saves in three seconds to preserve the two-goal lead. He denied Egor Chinakhov at 18:10, turned away a wrist shot from Ben Kindel on the rebound before sliding well out of the crease and extended his right pad to get just enough of another rebound chance from Tommy Novak.
"I'm just trying to do my job out there," Hofer said. "Obviously, just trying to battle and compete. Made a couple saves. It was good."
St. Louis had 22 shots on goal in the second period after being held to five in the first.
"We've struggled with some second periods lately," Pittsburgh captain Sidney Crosby said. "We've had good firsts, and then, I don't know."
Snuggerud extended the Blues' lead to 4-1 on his second of the game and 12th goal this season at 7:09 of the third period with a wrist shot above the crease off a pass from Thomas below the goal line.
Rakell cut it to 4-2 at 15:24 on a one-timer set up by Crosby with Silovs pulled for the extra attacker.
Holloway scored an empty-net goal at 17:16 for the 5-2 final.
"We've just got to try to work through it," Crosby said. "We've got to stick together. That's the only way. That hasn't changed. ... It's been different things. We always talk about consistency. If we can find that, we give ourselves a chance. And we just haven't found it."
NOTES: Thomas reached 344 assists in the NHL, passing Alex Pietrangelo (341) for the third-most in Blues history behind Bernie Federko (721) and Brett Hull (409). ... Penguins defenseman Kris Letang had the secondary assist on Rakell's first goal to reach 817 NHL points (179 goals, 638 assists), tying Victor Hedman (817 points with the Tampa Bay Lightning) for the eighth-most by a defenseman with a single franchise. ... Pittsburgh forward Nicholas Robertson, who is third on the team with seven goals behind Rakell and Novak (eight), did not play because of a lower-body injury sustained in an optional morning skate Thursday. ... Van Riemsdyk had an assist and a block in 19:35 of ice time in his return from missing 15 games with a lower-body injury.