With a 1-0 lead, the Avalanche had the opportunity to build off their momentum as they received a power play at 2:27, but didn't convert.
The Coyotes then tied the score 1-1 at 6:50 as they capitalized on their first of two goals in the frame, both off quick-transition plays.
Off a quick zone entry where Byram lost an edge, the Coyotes implemented some quick passing across the Avalanche's zone before their defense could get set up. The play resulted in Lawson Crouse taking the puck to the net from the left faceoff circle, where Georgiev denied his backhanded chance, but McBain put the rebound away cleanly on the backdoor.
Late in the frame, Arizona then took a 2-1 lead as they entered the zone with Hayton carrying the puck below the goal line. Hayton pumped the brakes, turned and curled to face the net before sending a pass across the slot to Keller. From inside the right faceoff circle, Keller hesitated before sneakily slipping his shot through Georgiev's pads at 17:18.
Down 2-1, Colorado tilted the ice with a commanding effort in the second period where they outshot Arizona 14-8 and came up with an equalizer on a power play just over the game's midway mark.
The Avalanche started the second frame off with another power play at 2:14, but didn't convert and then seemingly tied the score up 2-2 at 6:31, but the goal was immediately waved off by the officials. It looked as though Malgin buried his second goal of the game as he put away the puck past Ingram's pads on the doorstep, but the Coyotes' netminder had previously clasped the puck in his glove to blow the play dead.