Some of the Stars' best players were making egregious mistakes, as Miro Heiskanen and Jamie Benn each flung pucks into dangerous areas, and the Stars as a team had 18 giveaways. DeBoer called out Jason Robertson, who had two assists, for also having too many reckless plays.
But Oettinger held strong and allowed a few skilled plays to stand out for the Stars. Robertson made a deft tip pass to Roope Hintz in transition, and Hintz busted in with speed, beating Penguins goalie Casey DeSmith. That goal held up until Pittsburgh tied things up on a Sidney Crosby goal in the second period. The score was tied 1-1 in the third, and Dallas had already fumbled a few power play opportunities when the Stars were given their third of the game at the 8:55 mark.
Dallas finally worked the puck around and Heiskanen sent a perfect pass to Joe Pavelski in front of the net for a redirection goal. Benn added a nice rebound goal less than two-minutes later, and that would prove to be the game-winner. Evgenii Dadonov fed Max Domi for a shot and Benn then made a nice recovery of the puck before stuffing in his 31st goal of the year.
It was huge because Pittsburgh cut the deficit to 3-2 with six minutes remaining. The Penguins pulled the goalie late and received the advantage of a late power play. However, Oettinger made some big stops and the team made some big blocks. Dallas finished with 21 blocked shots and even Tyler Seguin got in on the action.
The skilled forward was returning after missing six games with a leg laceration, and he clearly had to battle through the game. But DeBoer said plays like the blocked shot show just how tough Seguin is.
"He gutted it out tonight," DeBoer said. "He came back early from a tough injury. He wanted to be in the lineup and I give him full credit. He made a huge block at the end and dealing with what he's dealing with, to stand in front of a puck takes a lot of guts. He wasn't perfect, but I admire his courage and getting out there and battling with us."
Seguin said the game was a process and that he was happy to be a part of the team on the ice. A big part of that game was being able to watch Oettinger.
"He's just elite," Seguin said. "There's no reason for him to call himself out after last game. Even though he did, he responded. He's got a heavy workload and he's the backbone."