The Sabres got the start they wanted following a shutout loss to Montreal on Friday. They were outshooting the Rangers 18-6 when Chris Kreider opened the scoring for the Rangers with 3:31 remaining in the first period, on a crossing feed from Mika Zibanejad. Jimmy Vesey added a second goal 1:33 later.
New York poured on three more goals in the second period - one at even-strength from Neal Pionk followed by two on the power play from Zibanejad and Vesey - to extends its lead to 5-0.
"All the things we did with the puck, we did really well," Sabres coach Phil Housley said. "But when we didn't have it, we didn't defend well. We lost coverage. Guys were beating us up the ice, and I think it goes back to having respect for our own end and our own goaltender."
On all five of their goals, the Rangers found space and were able to take uncontested shots. Kreider was alone at the doorstep when he caught the pass from Zibanejad to open the scoring, then later returned the favor when he burst behind the defense and made the same pass to set up Zibanejad's goal.
Vesey was alone on both of his goals. Pionk's goal came on a one-time shot from the left faceoff circle.
"It's just decisions without the puck," defenseman Marco Scandella said. "We have to get better. We got a lot of shots on net, but we didn't play defense. … We've got to play harder, that's it."
Robin Lehner, making his first appearance since March 15, was pulled after allowing four goals on 12 shots in 28:23. Linus Ullmark allowed one goal on 11 shots in relief.
"I can't fault Robin for any of those goals," Housley said. "We missed coverages, missed picking up guys. I don't think he had a chance. But you give up four goals on [12] shots, I was just trying to save him a little bit and maybe send a message to our team."
Reinhart finally found the back of the net on the power play with 4:34 remaining in the third period, ending rookie goaltender Alexandar Georgiev's bid for his first career shutout. Reinhart was stationed in front of Georgiev and deflected a slap shot from Kyle Okposo, reaching the 20-goal mark for the second time in his young career.