Tavares no longer plays for the Islanders, having signed a seven-year, $77 million contract with the Toronto Maple Leafs on July 1, 2018.
"We had a contingency plan in case the Islanders passed on Tavares, but I was never concerned that was going to happen," Lawton said. "I spoke to (then-Islanders GM) Garth Snow a number of times, and it was very obvious to me [whom] they were taking."
Not everyone was as convinced of that as Lawton was.
"I remember hearing from the media apparently at the time that the Islanders were debating between Tavares and Hedman," said Martin Biron, a goalie on the 2009-10 Islanders. "But my feeling at training camp through ownership, Garth, everyone, was that they had planned on drafting Tavares from the moment they knew they had the No. 1 pick.
"Now, was that a way to promote the whole thing? Maybe. But I remember the first couple of years people were talking that Hedman was just OK. He was not a superstar. And defensemen don't usually turn into superstars like Victor Hedman for a few years. I think the Islanders were like, 'We wanted a stud forward like Tavares from the get-go, we always wanted him,' and I think that's a narrative they always had."
Whatever rumblings were coming out of Long Island, Lawton wasn't taking any chances. He wanted to make sure Lightning management knew as much as it could about Tavares, Hedman and forward Matt Duchene, the three prospects they were considering at No. 2.
"We brought all three down to Tampa, which is not uncommon," Lawton said. "The uncommon thing is, we brought all three of them down together. All three of them were down together for a few days, and we went through a process we had at the time to evaluate young people. They all did incredible."