Josh Bailey ended a 10-game goal drought with a one-timer from the slot to give New York a 3-2 lead at 14:51 of the second period. It was Bailey's second goal of the season, first since Jan. 31.
"It felt good; obviously, it had been a little while since I shot one in the net," Bailey said. "It felt good. It was a good all-around play. Just found a way to get one point, a little disappointed in the result. But the beauty of this league is we're going to get a chance coming real quick at 5 o'clock tomorrow night to redeem ourselves."
Crosby and Letang scored 26 seconds apart after Nelson put the Islanders ahead 1-0 at 18:40 of the first period, and Mathew Barzal made it 2-0 at 1:34 of the second. Nelson redirected a pass from Oliver Wahlstrom to score in a third straight game against the Penguins, and a wrist shot from Barzal went off Penguins defenseman John Marino's stick and in glove side.
"We played a pretty good game," Nelson said. "Start of the second and start of the third, they get three goals in the first couple minutes of each period. … [We] would like to come away with two points."