"The Bobby Nystrom overtime game-winner to win the Cup is still as bothersome to me as when I was growing up," Tirico said.
When Tirico worked at ESPN in the 1990s, he had Hartford Whalers season tickets. He sat in the fourth row by the Zamboni entrance in 1996-97, the season before the Whalers became the Carolina Hurricanes. Inside a clear paperweight, he has preserved a Hartford playoff ticket from a game that was never played.
Tirico moved to Ann Arbor, Michigan, when the Detroit Red Wings were one of the best teams in the NHL. He got tickets from a friend and sat high in the stands at Joe Louis Arena for Game 7 of the 2002 Western Conference Final -- behind the net from which Colorado Avalanche goalie Patrick Roy was pulled in the second period after allowing six goals. Detroit went on to win 7-0.
"It may be the loudest I've heard a building," Tirico said.
Lately, Tirico has been at NHL events as a host for NBC -- from the Winter Classic to the All-Star Game to the Stanley Cup Final -- and at NHL games preparing for this one. He has been speaking to play-by-play broadcasters on radio and television, as well as studying their calls.
"Hockey TV broadcasters end up using a lot of geography in calling the game, which is absent from every other game usually," Tirico said. "Blue line. Red line. Circle. Dot. All that stuff. Well, we can see that, so it's an interesting way the game has been called, the way it's evolved. It's the closest thing to a radio call on TV of any sport.
"So you just kind of go to school as a broadcaster who's done hundreds of games and then figure out, 'OK, how does my skill set best fit in executing this?'"
Ed Olczyk thinks Tirico will do just fine. He has worked with Tirico before on horse racing and will be his color analyst, with Brian Boucher between the benches.
"You look at what he's accomplished, and knowing that he's a big hockey fan, I mean, it's just kind of a natural," Olczyk said. "I look forward to being with him on his maiden voyage. It will be very comfortable, and we'll be there to support him. He's a talented guy."
One takeaway from Tirico's preparation has been a deeper appreciation of broadcasters such as Mike Emrick, Kenny Albert, John Forslund, Ken Daniels and Pat Foley.
"The bar is so high because there are so many great announcers that you know you're not going to be that good unless you do it all the time," Tirico said. "There's a reason that the best are the best."
For now, at least, the plan is for this to be one and done. But the experience will be valuable.
"I've always been a big believer that if you're in the studio at any point it's really good to get out and cover a game, because I think you do in-depth research that reminds you when you're in the studio of the things you really don't know unless you are spending those hours on a team," Tirico said. "Hopefully in the long run it will help any time when I'm around the NHL, but even [with] other sports in general. It's great to expose yourself to something new."