But his mistake was glaring. He overskated the puck behind the net, allowing Bryan Rust to set up Nick Bonino for the final goal of the game.
That prompted Vigneault to make Skjei a healthy scratch for the first time in 36 games this season. Skjei, 22, acknowledged that at this stage of his young career, "the huge thing is consistency," and he's been working on that while adjusting to the grind of the NHL season.
"This year, especially with a lot of games in a lot of days, you've got to bring your game every night," he said. "I think I've played pretty well and have gotten a few points, so I've just to keep it up."
While averaging 16:46 in ice time per game, which ranks sixth among the Rangers defensemen, Skjei is second on the Rangers and second among NHL rookie defensemen with 14 assists. His 15 points put him third among Rangers defensemen behind Ryan McDonagh (20) and Nick Holden (16).
Zach Werenski of the Columbus Blue Jackets, who has 15 assists and 21 points, is the only rookie defenseman in the League with more assists and points. But Skjei, who had four goals and 24 assists in 68 games with Hartford of the American Hockey League last season, said there is room for improvement in the offensive side of his game.
"Definitely I can learn some more things, and I've been working on that in practice and watching other guys on our team and good power-play quarterbacks and taking stuff from them," he said.
Skjei (6-foot-3, 211 pounds) entered this season with confidence that he could play in the NHL after getting in seven regular-season games and five games in the Stanley Cup Playoffs with the Rangers last season.
"Obviously that's the highest-paced hockey and getting that experience last year at the end of the year was huge," he said. "It taught me a lot going into this year to make the jump to playing the full year in the NHL."
Learning to pace himself and get his rest between games has been one of the biggest adjustments Skjei has had to make since leaving the University of Minnesota after three seasons to turn pro in 2015. During college he never played more than 40 games in a season.
He's almost played that many already this season in less than three months.
"You have to take care of your body and on your days off just get away and try to get your mind off hockey and relax," Skjei said. "It's hard but everyone in the League is playing a ton of games, so it's no excuse. You have to take care of your body and be aware of what you put in your body."