"At the time, when you looked at the roster and, obviously, the position in the standings, it seemed like it was one of the best teams I've been a part of," Shattenkirk said. "I had played on some great teams in St. Louis as well. You always want to make sure you have a chance, and I felt like when we got here, the sky was the limit for us."
The Capitals, who haven't advanced past the second round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs since their lone Stanley Cup Final appearance in 1998, hoped adding Shattenkirk would put them over the top. A skilled, puck-moving defenseman with a right-handed shot, Shattenkirk gave them arguably the deepest defense in the NHL, joining a group that included John Carlson, Matt Niskanen, Dmitry Orlov, Karl Alzner, Brooks Orpik and
Nate Schmidt.
But the Capitals again fell short of expectations, losing to the Pittsburgh Penguins in the Eastern Conference Second Round for the second season in a row.
"It was tough," Shattenkirk said. "There's obviously been a lot of tough losses here in the past, and I think we were just a little tight in the playoffs. Nothing really clicked and we didn't really seem to hit on all cylinders all of the time. That was frustrating for a lot of us."
Because of their depth, the Capitals used Shattenkirk mostly in their third defense pair with either Orpik or Schmidt at even strength, but he ran the point on their first power-play unit. The results were mixed.
Shattenkirk had 14 points (two goals, 12 assists) in 19 regular-season games with the Capitals and six points (one goal, five assists) in 13 games in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. His highlight was scoring in overtime in Game 3 in Pittsburgh.
But Shattenkirk struggled at times defensively, particularly during the Capitals' six-game win against the Toronto Maple Leafs in the first round. He played better later against the Penguins, after he was paired with Schmidt.