The 6-foot-1, 215-pound right wing slipped to 18 goals and 44 points in 1993-94, then had just six goals and 19 points in 45 games in 1994-95. But his magic in the postseason was rekindled; he led all skaters with 13 goals to be voted winner of the Conn Smythe Trophy, the Devils sweeping the Detroit Red Wings in the Stanley Cup Final to win their first title.
“I think it’s just unbelievable,” Lemieux said, having gotten under the skin of virtually every NHL opponent by then. “I look at some of the names on this trophy and on the Stanley Cup, it’s incredible. To be a part of the team that won the first Stanley Cup for the New Jersey Devils, who would have thought it?
“I played well,” he added of his own playoff performance. “It's very special. The Stanley Cup is what we play for. To be the most hated man in hockey and have your name on the Conn Smythe Trophy, it’s special.”
But Lemieux was on the move again, dealt to Colorado on Sept. 3, 1995, as part of a three-team trade. He scored 39 goals for the Avalanche in 1995-96, their first season in Denver after having relocated from Quebec, then became the 10th player to win the Cup in consecutive years with different teams when he helped Colorado to its first title, scoring 12 points (five goals, seven assists) in 19 games.
He forever cemented his reputation as Public Enemy No. 1 in Game 6 of the Western Conference Final, hitting Detroit Red Wings forward Kris Draper from behind, hard into the boards. Draper suffered facial injuries that would require surgery, Lemieux receiving a major, game misconduct and two-game suspension.
The Red Wings exacted their revenge the following March in a wild night between two heated opponents whose rivalry reached dramatic heights.
Lemieux scored 26 goals in 1997-98 and 27 in 1998-99, but early in the 1999-2000 season was traded back to New Jersey. He scored 17 goals in 70 games for the Devils, then had 10 points (four goals, six assists) in 23 playoff games to become a four-time Cup-winner when they defeated the Dallas Stars in a six-game Final.