"What makes him special is his defensive play. Not everyone focuses on defense like he does and wants to play the game the right way. That's why he's rewarded because he does things the right way."
Carlyle spotted that too before he returned as Ducks coach. Hence the comparison to Alfredsson, who scored 444 goals in his NHL career and had a 103-point season in 2005-06 with the Senators.
"[Silfverberg] had that type of demeanor about him," Carlyle said. "Good on the defensive side but found ways to provide offense. He's a dynamic player, a good checker."
Silfverberg's second goal, at 4:56 of the third period that gave the Ducks a 5-3 lead, was challenged by Oilers coach Todd McLellan, who claimed Silfverberg was offside. It was upheld by video review. Silfverberg said the longer the review lasted, the more nervous he felt.
The often-frantic pace felt like a throwback game. The Ducks led 3-0 less than 12 minutes in, but the Oilers tied it 3-3 at 8:40 of the second period. Chris Wagner put the Ducks ahead for good 48 seconds later.
Ducks goaltender John Gibson, who made 24 saves, was especially sharp when he needed to be with a series of highlight-reel moments in the second period.
"He knows how to stay in those games and keep fighting," Cogliano said. "He made some big saves. He gave up three, but at the end of the day, there was some really big saves that could have blown the game open.
"That's where he shines. When things can go sideways, he usually pulls it together. And we're going to need him to."