0EFF0CD9-B957-4B01-97D0-731707E7242F

Matthew Schaefer did what no New York Islanders defenseman had done in 44 years; score a hat trick.  

Schaefer became the first Isles' defenseman since Denis Potvin on March 4,1982 to record the feat. The historic mark meant Schaefer went home with a handful of new hats and the postgame Oar as the 19-year-old helped propel the Islanders to a 5-1 win over the Columbus Blue Jackets on Tuesday, Nov. 17.  

"He amazes us every single day," Anthony Duclair said of Schaefer. "I don't think I've ever seen last year, an 18-year-old defenseman come the way he did, and this year, follow it up. He's obviously a special player, and he's going to be for a very long time. So, very, very blessed to be playing with him for sure." 

The young defenseman has tallied back-to-back three-point games, recording three goals against Columbus on Tuesday and three helpers against the Anaheim Ducks on Saturday – also a career-first.

"We're watching greatness," Mathew Barzal said of Schaefer.  

“If there was a question about the Norris [Trophy], he's got to be right there if not the front runner. It's pretty special. It's fun to watch, that's for sure... You know what it is, it’s fun to watch someone with so much enthusiasm on the ice.” 

Schaefer started his scoring spree in the first period, corralling a loose puck and letting it rip from distance past Cam Talbot's stick side to give the Islanders a 2-0 lead.  

Schaefer added his second goal of the night in the third period on a feed from Ryan Pulock, but his night didn't end there. The 2026 Calder Trophy winner took advantage of an empty net to seal his first career hat trick on a pass from Simon Holmström. Holmström recorded his first hat trick in the previous game against Anaheim.

CBJ@NYI: Schaefer has a hat trick against the Blue Jackets

"It's awesome. It's also not very surprising to be honest," Duclair said of the historic nature of the hat trick. "The way he's flying around, shooting a puck, it seems like he's a forward, a defenseman, center. He's all over the place. So, he's been awesome. It's not gonna be his last one. So, get ready for more for sure." 

Schaefer has now notched 24 points (9G, 15A) on the season, which leads the Islanders. Schaefer is tied with Bo Horvat and Holmström for the team lead in goals and leads the Isles in assists. Schaefer is riding a six-game point streak with 10 points (5G, 5A) over that span. He has tallied a point in 12 of his last 13 contests.  

Schaefer is tied with Adam Fox for third most points by a defenseman in the NHL.  

"It's a privilege to coach a guy like that," Islanders' Head Coach Pete DeBoer said of Schaefer. "To be able to stand there and watch that every night because you know he is a generational talent, and Long Island and the people of Long Island are fortunate to have him, and I know they know that. He's a special player, special kid."

Schaefer's MSGSN Interview After First Hat Trick

Tony DeAngelo was also awarded the hardworking helmet. DeAngelo recorded a two-point game with a goal and an assist. 

DeAngelo tallied a helper on Duclair's opening goal in the first period and found the back of the net in the third. DeAngelo skated toward the net and on the backhand, slipped one past Talbot's stick to give the Islanders a 4-1 advantage. 

"It was nice for Tony to get on the board," DeBoer said. "He's been a little snake bit, so some good stuff happening."

CBJ@NYI: DeAngelo scores goal against Cam Talbot

Related Content