One night at the bar he spotted Gamper at a pinball machine wearing a Utica Mohawks t-shirt. While a shirt for an Eastern League Hockey team (the Mohawks played in Utica for two years before relocating to Salem, Virginia in 1980) may go over the head of most people, it was a conversation starter for a keen hockey fan like DiNapoli.
"It kicked off our conversation with hockey," DiNapoli said. "Then we were both like okay, we're in a gay bar, so that obviously led to other conversations."
The couple has been together for 40 years and like any love story, it has its magic moments. On New Year's Eve, DiNapoli had initially turned down an invitation from Gamper to meet in Manhattan, feeling beholden to a friend he'd made plans with. When that friend bailed on the plans, that enabled DiNapoli to hop on a train and surprise Gamper at work at the New York Hilton, the first of many New Year's spent together.
"And all because of the damn hockey and the Islanders," DiNapoli said.
The Mohawks too and DiNapoli joked that when he gets mad at Gamper, he yells at the Mohawks pennant.
"Every time I get mad at him I have a pennant, a flag of the Utica Mohawks, that I start yelling at," DiNapoli laughed. "I say 'this is your fault, and the Islanders fault.'"
There's more to their enduring relationship than just hockey, but it's a central tenant. They've done countless Islanders road trips, using the team as an excuse to travel around North America. DiNapoli was even in Vancouver to watch the Islanders win their third Stanley Cup in 1982 against the Canucks.
"We watch all the games together and we've taken a lot of road trips," DiNapoli said. "We've been all over the country, making vacations where we enjoy going to the sites, seeing new cities, seeing the history, seeing museums, and then we go to a hockey game."
DiNapoli's fan credentials are up there with the best of fans. He attended the Islanders first-ever exhibition game against the New York Rangers on Sept. 27, 1972 with his dad, a tradition they kept up for 15 years. Even after his father became a snowbird, DiNapoli continued the tradition and has attended every Islanders home opener including the first game at UBS Arena this season. You definitely saw him, as he was the fan outfitted in the custom Islanders tuxedo and top hat, a costume made for him by a friend who works on Broadway.