At 12:39, the Avalanche received their first power play of the game and capitalized to tie the score up 1-1 as they scored their fifth-straight goal on the man advantage. Cale Makar snapped the puck to Rantanen inside of the right faceoff circle. The Finnish winger looked to send a one-timer pass to Valeri Nichushkin for an easy tap-in, but the puck instead hit off Toronto's Jake McCabe and slipped through Samsonov's pads.
Neither team found the back of the net in the second period despite both teams receiving two power plays each. Colorado held the Leafs' high-octane offense to just four shots in the middle frame, while the Avalanche put up 10.
The third period featured tight-checking and end-to-end action as both teams sought to attain a difference maker, but neither team was able to and the game was sent to overtime.
In the extra period, both teams generated some dynamic looks but the Avalanche held the Leafs without a shot, meanwhile Colorado produced two quality looks in overtime that Samsonov denied.
During the shootout, Rodrigues was stopped as Samsonov made a pad save and Georgiev denied Auston Matthews with a toe save. The two clutch plays to secure the shootout win occurred as MacKinnon netted the lone shootout goal as he squeezed his shot under Samsonov's right arm and Georgiev followed it up by poke checking the puck away from Mitchell Marner.