After winning Game 1 on Wednesday, the Stars had a chance Saturday to take a 2-0 series lead and put the Predators on their heels. But Nashville pushed hard in Game 2 and five minutes into overtime, Predators forward Craig Smith scored from the bottom of the left circle after a Mattias Ekholm shot rebounded off traffic, and the Stars will head back to Dallas tied 1-1 in the series.
"We're going to move on from this game as quickly as we moved on from winning the last game," said Stars center Tyler Seguin. "It's a seven-game series. We came into Nashville wanting to get one, wanting to steal one on the road. We did that. We're excited to get home and play in front of our fans."
The Stars expected a better Nashville team Saturday, and they got it. Nashville outshot the Stars 43-23 including 31-14 during 5-on-5 play. Ben Bishop was excellent in goal, stopping 41 of 43 shots.
"We knew we were going to get Nashville's best and we did. They were the better team tonight," said Stars coach Jim Montgomery. "Probably not for Bish, we're not in overtime. We got to come back, and we will. We'll be better."
There were missed opportunities for the Stars, who went 0-for-6 on the power play in the game.
The first period had 10 minutes of special teams play. The Stars went 0-for-3 with the man-advantage and couldn't cash in on a four-minute power play after Ekholm took an interference penalty and then had two more minutes tacked on for unsportsmanlike conduct.
The Predators were 0-for-2 on the power play in the first.
The Stars got the game's first goal at 1:59 of the second period. Ekholm turned the puck over to Seguin, and he set up Jamie Benn, who scored from close range to put the Stars up 1-0.
The Predators answered just under two minutes later when Austin Watson sent the puck from behind the net to Rocco Grimaldi who scored from the top of the crease to make it a 1-1 game at 3:56 of the second.
There were more power plays in the second with the Stars getting two more chances and the Predators one, but neither team could take advantage.
The Stars had a couple of quality chances in the third.
Predators goaltender Pekka Rinne made a great save on a close-range bid by Seguin, and Jason Dickinson rang a shot off the post. The Stars missed on their sixth power play of the game when Smith was called for roughing six minutes into the third, and the game would end up in overtime where Smith scored from the bottom of the left circle.
"Opportunity we missed, but we got a win in the first game here," said Bishop, who said he didn't see the puck on Smith's game-winner. "Just get home now and worry about Game 3."