That Foegele is still learning to utilize his size and strength might be because those weren't assets for him when he was younger.
"I was a lot smaller than everyone else," he said. "Everyone has their own path. It doesn't really matter how you start. It's not a sprint. It's a marathon."
Growing up in the Toronto suburb of Markham, Ontario, Foegele played youth hockey alongside a host of future NHL players, including on a peewee team that included Travis Dermott (Toronto Maple Leafs), Sam Bennett (Calgary Flames) and Connor McDavid (Edmonton Oilers). McDavid's father, Brian, was the coach.
"We had a pretty good team that year," Foegele said.
But Foegele was still undersized at 5-7 and about 140 pounds when he was initially passed over in the Ontario Hockey League Priority Selection in 2012. By then, he was playing for St. Andrew's College, a prep school in Aurora, Ontario.
From 2013 into 2014, Foegele grew six inches and gained 30 pounds. He was already committed to the University of New Hampshire when Kingston selected him in the seventh round of the 2014 OHL draft and had 16 points (five goals, 11 assists) in 34 games as a freshman in 2014-15.
"He was like this thin little kid who came in and everyone didn't really know what to think of him," said Hurricanes defenseman Brett Pesce, who was a junior at New Hampshire that season. "He was very raw. … I remember talking to a bunch of buddies. We all saw the potential and now he's really coming into his own."
Foegele left New Hampshire five games into 2015-16 to join Kingston and had 48 points (13 goals, 35 assists) in 52 regular-season OHL games that season before getting 10 points (eight goals, two assists) in nine playoff games.
A trade to Erie on Jan. 2, 2017 provided the chance for him play on one of the most dynamic lines in the OHL with Alex DeBrincat and Dylan Strome (now teammates on the Chicago Blackhawks). Foegele helped Erie to the OHL championship and a runner-up finish (to host Windsor) in the Memorial Cup that season with 26 points (13 goals 13 assists) in 22 playoff games, including the overtime goal in Game 7 of the second round against London.
"That's one of the biggest goals he's ever scored and for our team it was huge," Strome said. "He fit in really well. He can play with anyone. He can play on the fourth line or the first line. He complements a lot of players."