It wasn't difficult for him to set that example. In many ways that's how he approaches every day with the Rangers.
"Every year is different with different things going on and the team playing different, but he just plays the same way no matter what," Rangers defenseman Dan Girardi said. "He's our rock back there. It's pretty much all you can ask for in a player and obviously your captain, to do everything and anything it takes to win."
That includes setting an example for young players like rookie defenseman Brady Skjei, a Minnesotan like McDonagh.
"He's always the last guy off the ice [at practice]," Skjei said. "That's very noticeable. I try to stay out there as long as I can before the guys kick us off and we're usually out there pretty late, and it's very consistent that he's one of the last ones off the ice and always working on stuff."
Defenseman Adam Clendening, a healthy scratch for 31 of 35 games from Oct. 23-Jan. 3, said McDonagh kept constant tabs on him during that stretch to make sure his spirits were up, to make him feel like he was still very much a part of the team and would be needed, as he is now.
"He would always check up on me, ask 'How's it going,' that kind of thing," Clendening said. "He is what he is, your captain and everything you'd expect a captain to be."
It's easier for McDonagh to do everything else as captain when he feels like he's doing his part on the ice. He didn't always feel that way last season, especially at the end, when he was playing with a broken right hand which caused him to miss the first two games of the Rangers' five-game loss to the Penguins in the Eastern Conference First Round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs.
The World Cup gave him a chance to start quickly this season. He hasn't slowed down.
"I know he's really driven this year," Girardi said. "You can really see it in him. He's trying to lead the way, to play the right way. He's doing everything for us."